February 22, 2018 | Rome, Italy | °C

Taxes vs. penalties

By Don Carroll
Published: 2018-01-31

The new U.S, Tax Cuts and Jobs Act that went into effect on Dec. 22, 2017 won't have much of an effect on U.S. citizens who reside in Italy and paying taxes here. That's what I recently told Martin, an American tax client and long-term resident of Italy. Instead, I went on, what he and all U.S. expatriates need to be absolutely certain of is that they've declared all the accounts they hold in financial institutions outside Italy on their Italian returns.

Martin recently received a letter from one of the U.S. institutions where he has an investment account. The bank requested that he complete and return a self-certification form to declare his citizenship and country of tax residency, if other than the U.S. The form also required that he provide his tax code in the country of tax residency as well as his consent to share that information with local tax authorities.

Semi-retired, Martin was once a very successful CEO and still sits on several boards of companies that have headquarters in Belgium and Denmark. Though savvy in his work, he's nonchalant about his personal taxes and tends to follow what his heart tells him is "fair and just" when declaring his income and their sources. Unfortunately, it's a strategy that leaves him battered and bruised every time. Yet he persists "on principle."

I ran down the not-always-simple situation for him (and you might consider asking for the same from your own lawyer).

Seen from the U.S. vantage point alone, the new bill could have consequences on certain individuals. There are new income tax brackets and rates, which beginning in 2018 may reduce Martin's tax load. The moving expense deduction has also been removed. Some itemized deductions have been capped ($10,000 total in real estate, sales, state and local taxes), limited (mortgage interest up to $750,000 in mortgage debt), or eliminated (unreimbursed employee expenses and tax preparation, safety deposit box and investor advisory fees).

The personal exemption has been eliminated and the standard deduction has doubled. The child tax credit has been increased. Beginning in 2019, alimony will no longer be deductible by the paying spouse.

Up and down, up and down — will any of this really matter to him? Maybe. To what degree — again, based on the calculation of U.S. taxes only — will naturally depend on individual circumstances. I told Martin we could do an estimate of how his 2018 U.S. taxes would look based on the new law.

Bottom line, U.S. expatriates examining the new law must still take into consideration what has not changed. The foreign earned income exclusion, net investment income and alternative minimum taxes remain intact. So do Italian income taxes. Therein, of course, lies the rub.

Italian taxes do not take into consideration the deductions the U.S. may confer. Deductions under the Italian system are lower and the tax on earned income is higher. For many who work, this means that by combining foreign earned income exclusion in the U.S. and paying taxes to Italy on the balance, no income taxes remain due the U.S.

But remember this: the Net Investment Income Tax and the Alternative Minimum Tax are still taxes, not penalties assessed against capital. They have to be paid.

Italy has required its tax residents, including U.S. expatriates, to report investments and real estate held outside of Italy since 1991. Failing to do so risks fines of up to 30 percent of the amount not reported. Being cavalier about these demands, and the penalties for failing to comply with them, is most definitely the wrong approach.

Print | Email | | | 1 2 | Full Page

CLOSING ARGUMENT

Don Carroll

Taxes vs. penalties

The new U.S. tax law is unlikely to change much for American expats, but keep an eye out for Italian penalties.

Icebergs and rapids

Italy has many flaws, but its attention to health care isn't one, something the U.S. should learn from.

Dangers at face value

It's time for the Big 5 social media giants, Facebook, Google, Twitter, Instagram, and LinkedIn to put an end to stalling and open their gates.


NOTEBOOK

Madeleine Johnson

Cui bono

The way Italian politics has been conducted for decades can help American seeking the how's and why's of flip-flopping Donald Trump.

A new winter order

Moving from Milan to small town New Hampshire quickly alters your view of what Christmas, and winter, mean.


BIO-LINGUAL

Lorien Menhennett

Running the mental gantlet

Medical school can sometimes mean pushing hard to find out just what it is you're expected to do.


THE ECONOMIST

Mark Bassani

The Bitcoin conundrum

The digital currency has made waves in recent months, soaring and dipping, but behind it is a far bigger question.


AMERICAN GIRL

Madeline Klosterman

Come ti chiami?

Falling in love with Italy is the easy part, but it doesn't include learning the language.


PSYCH DEPT.

Elaine Luti

Annoying at any age

Some parents unfairly bash their kids for misbehaving in endless airport lines. But who wouldn’t be bored, if not exasperated?


CLOSING ARGUMENT ARCHIVE


Day and Boarding International High School in the Heart of Rome

Everything you need to know about visiting or moving to Tuscany, Italy.