February 27, 2017 | Rome, Italy | Partly cloudy 16°C

Damnatio memoriae


Statue of Andrew Jackson, general and president, in New Orleans' Jackson Square.
By Jacob Carroll
Published: 2016-12-11
A

ncient Romans coined the term damnatio memoriae for the practice of erasing any memory of political adversaries and traitors to the state. In times of political unrest, the suppression of an image, a culture, or a political power served as a tangible, aesthetic way of asserting dominance and of setting a new direction. Bereft of paper and online trails, the ancient world was in a better position to rework public thinking with relatively minimal efforts. History could be eradicated.

Today, similar reworking is more nuanced, both morally and practically. In recent months, protests in New Orleans against the presence of statues honoring Confederate leaders Gen. Robert E. Lee and Confderate President Jefferson Davis among them have intensified, sometimes taking a violent turn. A grassroots organization called Take 'Em Down NOLA recently lead an attempt to tear down a statue of President Andrew Jackson, now denounced as a 19th-century slave owner. While city government claims it seeks the removal of the memorials, it also says its efforts have been slowed down by competing lawsuits.

Take 'Em Down NOLA demonstrated its impatience with the bureaucratic and legal process by organizing a late September march to draw attention to the immediate need to remove the statues. Enter former Klu Klux Klan leader David Duke, who vowed to resist the protest. On Sept. 24, the two sides scuffled in the city's Jackson Square. New Orleans police made seven arrests.

In a previous column I argued that Confederate memorials, whether to men or battles, are dangerous because they can be perceived by some as government-endorsed symbols of oppression and because they silently confer a sense of belonging and glorification to extremist thinkers. Dylan Storm Roof, charged with nine murders in the 2015 Charleston church massacre, was emboldened by Confederate battle flag, which he posed beside. I suggested the way forward was not to ignore the Confederacy existed but to deter the honoring of symbols that drive people to unite in hatred. The key to this was and remains putting history in context.


The massive Robert E. Lee memorial could serve a historical purpose, if allowed to.

I was there as the mostly white Take 'Em Down NOLA crowd marched its way through the French Quarter. And watching made me believe more strongly than ever that a simple damnatio memoriae directed at the Confederacy gets society nowhere.

Concepts of history change. So do notions of progress, which now includes dialogue. Culture is no longer monolithic. What the bitter debate over the statues suggest is that to remove them is also to eliminate a conversation that desperately needs airing out. Erasing memorials doesn't eliminate the cancer any more than tearing down statues of Lenin and Stalin excise Communist sympathizers.

In a 2015 episode of TriPod New Orleans, a radio show about the city's 300 years of history, producer Laine Kaplan-Levenson noted that some 50 historic slave-trade sites remain unmarked in downtown New Orleans. Over all, only two markers point exist noting the city's role as the capital of the ante-bellum slave trade. One is across the Mississippi River from downtown New Orleans and mostly out of view, the other situated across the street from where it should be.

But if damnatio memoriae is an outdated practice, as I believe it is, what's the alternative? A national conversation comes to mind, one that places racism in a historical context. Instead of advocating for the destruction of statues and the abrogation of an unseemly past, we should be learning from the symbolic cues these monuments offer. For example, the Lee statue in New Orleans towers over the Lee Circle interchange. But the general's back is intentionally turned against the traditionally black and low-income neighborhoods. This placement could serve as a powerful reminder of the city's dark roots, but only of course if the statue carried a marker explaining Lee's life. Without such an explanation, it's a stand-alone memorial that teaches nothing. Tearing it down voids any possible lesson.

But those eager to create historical markers face their own set of obstacles. Telling the truth about historical figures can interfere with New Orleans' tourism of distraction, debauchery, pleasure- and beauty-seeking. Slave-trade markers would need to be located in front of hotels and private properties. Tourists and the industry behind them want no reminders of ugly history not when they're busy celebrating Mardi Gras. Markers also face the wrath of vandals. An Emmett Till memorial marker in Mississippi is riddled with bullet-holes, the Mississippi Clarion Ledger reported earlier this year.


Former Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke at the September memorial protest.

Marking the spot may not solve anything, I admit that, but it would at least represent a starting point. It would suggest a willingness to add layers of complexity and discourse to a history that's so far been muted. It remains a better choice than trying to throw away a past that won't be tossed.

In the song "Empire," David Byrne sings over a swell of organs and victorious trumpets: "The weak among us perish/the strong alone survive." But beneath the triumphal tone is one of rueful melancholy that acknowledges the limits of that battering cycle, and suggests another way.

Voices like thunder

Decisions like steel

The past and the future

They belong to us all ()

The world that we've created

The world that we've created

The world that we've created

By working hand in hand

By working hand in hand

Print | Email | | | 1

MILAN NOTEBOOK

Madeleine Johnson

Fit for Mozart

Swimming in a Milan temple of fascism can help with the creative process, no tyranny required.

Again and again

Pakistan, a country often pilloried by the West, affords one author with an oasis of energy.


AREA 51

Christopher P. Winner

Dream-killer

Italian media is tuning down its Trump coverage, in part to save its exalted vision of America.


PSYCH DEPT.

Elaine Luti

Seeking oxygen

When infants distract parents with squealing and crying, the name of the game is life-giving attention.


THE ECONOMIST

Vittorio Jucker

America first at what cost?

Donald Trump's door-slamming nationalism is likely to provoke hardcore global repercussions, some of which the U.S. may not find particularly enjoyable.


FIRST PERSON

Ghost town

Zeroing in on "dying" towns is a guilty pleasure for Italian story-hunters, but life in one is another story.


INTERVIEWS

Being Jeff Bursey

It took Canadian writer Bursey nearly 20 years to publish his first novel, but he persevered.


ESSAYS

Ties worth unbinding

Progress in LGBT rights remains painfully limited in Italy, but the underlying reasons suggest a change in approach.


AULD LANG SYNE

Auld Archive Staff

"Weigh your actions carefully"

Aldo Moro's efforts to secure his freedom changed the course of how terrorism was practiced.


MEMORY LANE

Dolce past

Once upon a time, Rome's Via Veneto was a hair haven for celebrities.


IDEAS ARCHIVE


Day and Boarding International High School in the Heart of Rome

Everything you need to know about visiting or moving to Tuscany, Italy.