July 29, 2010 | Rome, Italy | Partly Cloudy, 27°C
Search the archives:
Fiction
Nonfiction
Italy
Bios & Memoirs
History
Politics
Thrillers
Travel&Food
Sports&Leisure
   

History

Stalingrad

Beevor's World War II account is so chilling it stops you dead.

The Pirates Laffite

Homeland Security is nothing new, if your consider the pirates of New Orleans.

Jews and Power

If Jews are to survive, writes Ruth Wisse, they'd better take things into their own hands.

The Great Game: On Secret Service in High Asia

On Central Asia's mysteries, there's nobody better than Peter Hopkirk.

Africa: A Biography of the Continent

John Reader's generous accounting of Africa is both loving and critical.

The Berlin Wall: A World Divided, 1961-1989

Taylor's brilliant Berlin Wall history evokes the pathos and paranoia of the Cold War.

Constantine's Sword: The Church and the Jews

For James Carroll, Roman Catholicism needs more self-criticism in approaching Jews.

Nonfiction

Rome and Jerusalem: The Clash of Ancient Civilizations

Martin Goodman's account of the Roman-Jewish war gives Tacitus and Pliny their just due.

Summer for the Gods: The Scopes Trial and America's Continuing Debate Over Science and Religion

Edward J. Larson provides a judicious and brilliant account of the Scopes Trial.

The Pity of it All. A Portrait of A Portrait of Jews in Germany 1743-1933

The late Israeli writer Amos Elon's masterful history is one for the ages.




BOOK REVIEW
Who Will Write Our History? Emanuel Ringelblum, the Warsaw Ghetto, and the Oyneg Shabes Archive
By Samuel D. Kassow
Indiana University Press, 2007. 523 pages

This book almost defies description. It is as much a biography of the historian Emanuel Ringelblum as it is a history of the Oyneg Shabes, a resistance group in the Warsaw ghetto whose self-appointed mission it was to document life under Nazi occupation. The probability of their endeavor ever seeing the light of day was very small indeed. Only a few people involved in the group — originally composed of dozens of historians, economists, poets, and sociologists — survived the war. The only one who knew where to dig up the buried archives from the rubble of the destroyed ghetto saved himself by jumping from a train bound for Treblinka. Had he, too, perished it is likely that the entire archive would have been lost — as part of it still is — beneath the modern city of Warsaw.

The archive consists of documents of every type: diaries, interviews, historical and sociological studies, poems, photographs, children's art, candy wrappers. The idea was to leave a record of what the contributors increasingly understood to be a lost civilization—that of Polish Jewry. As the ghetto went from bad to worse, and the first reports of Nazi gassings and mass murder filtered in through underground channels, the Oyneg Shabes ("Sabbath joy" in Yiddish) realized they were responsible for writing their own history, lest it be blotted out forever.

To get the flavor of the context in which these people lived, wrote and died, we might read the words of Stanislaw Rozycki, a Jew who had made his way back to his native Warsaw from Lwow (Lviv). Crossing from the "Aryan" side to the ghetto, he wrote:

"I entered. I crossed the boundary not just of a residential quarter but of a zone of reality, because what I saw and experienced cannot be understood by our reason, thoughts, or imagination… the very act of crossing reminded me of some rite of passage, a ceremonial initiation, a crossing into the realm of Hades."

It was in this "realm of Hades" that the doomed Jews of Warsaw set down their own record of events. It was a daily struggle against poverty, hunger, displacement, disease, deportation, beatings and murder. The psychological terrorism of the Nazi program underscored all these factors, creating a hand-to-mouth existence with little or no hope for the future. If anyone ever lived "in the moment," these people did.

Under these conditions the Jewish underground revolted in an armed struggle against the Germans. It was a heroic, last-ditch effort by a people unjustly remembered for passivity in the face of Nazi atrocities. As historian Melvin Konner put it, "It took less time and thought for the Germans to conquer the French nation than to put down the Warsaw ghetto rebellion." Jewish resistance, Kassow’s book reminds us, had many faces.